The Original Josie's Pizza

Discover The Original Josie's Pizza in Columbus, OH, offering delicious tavern-style pizza, subs, stromboli, and more. Enjoy affordable prices, fresh mushrooms, BLT sandwiches, and friendly service at 894 W Broad St. Call +1 614-224-9637 today!

Welcome to The Original Josie's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

The Original Josie's Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza

The Original Josie's Pizza stands as a beloved cornerstone in Columbus, Ohio. Nestled at 894 W Broad St, this pizza restaurant offers a vibrant taste of local flavor. Known for its diverse menu, it caters to pizza lovers with its tavern-style pies and scrumptious subs. Customers rave about the affordable prices and generous portions, making it a favorite for families and friends gathering for dinner or lunch.

Enjoy a classic pepperoni pie or try a creamy BLT, while the laid-back atmosphere invites you to kick back and enjoy a meal with loved ones. On busy Fridays, it fills to capacity, signaling just how much the community cherishes this local gem.

Location & Contact

Address

894 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222, United States

Phone

+1 614-224-9637

Social Media

About

The Original Josie's Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza

The Original Josie's Pizza has earned its reputation as a community favorite through years of dedicated service and mouthwatering food. Since opening its doors, this establishment has delighted both residents and visitors with its exceptional offerings. What sets Josie's apart is its menu that extends beyond just pizza. Customers can savor hearty subs, flavorful strombolis, and vibrant salads.

In a city rich with culinary diversity, Josie's finds a special place in the hearts of those who appreciate traditional flavors from a locally owned kitchen. The extensive menu reflects a commitment to quality and affordability, making it easy for families to enjoy great meals without breaking the bank. Average prices hover around $9.23 across all dishes, ensuring that a night out is accessible for everyone.

The restaurant's busiest hours highlight its popularity, particularly during Friday dinner times, when the energy is palpable. Yet, it also knows how to accommodate those who prefer a quieter dining experience. By visiting during less crowded hours, diners can truly immerse themselves in the flavors without the rush. Each visit to Josie's comes with the promise of delicious food and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Within these walls, happy memories are created over shared pizzas and subs, year after year, building a sense of community around good food.

The Original Josie's Pizza shapes its identity not just through its menu, but through its customer-focused approach. Understanding the pulse of its patrons allows Josie's to continuously adapt and thrive in the heart of Columbus.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-11 PM
  • Wednesday4-11 PM
  • Thursday4-11 PM
  • Friday4-11 PM
  • Saturday4-11 PM

The Original Josie's Pizza boasts a wide variety of dishes that can satisfy any craving. With options ranging from large 14-inch pizzas to small 10-inch choices, everyone finds something to love. They serve classic toppings like pepperoni and extra cheese along with some unique offerings like a B.L.T. pizza. Subs also take center stage, featuring hearty Italian flavors with their famous meatball and double stromboli subs.

For those looking for lighter options, salads provide a refreshing balance. Appetizers shine with delectable garlic bread and various wing flavors, perfect for sharing. Every dish shows the restaurant's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, backed by their impressive menu of 59 items. The restaurant's bustling atmosphere, particularly on Friday nights, adds energy and excitement, marking it as the go-to spot for a hearty meal.

The Original Josie's Pizza

The exterior of The Original Josie's Pizza captures attention and invites a sense of community. Bright signage and a welcoming entrance draw in locals and newcomers alike. The casual vibe inside complements the lively atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for grabbing a quick bite or settling in for a leisurely meal. Some visitors often take advantage of the outdoor seating during pleasant weather, allowing them to enjoy their pizza while soaking up the local charm. The friendly staff enhances the warm ambiance, ensuring every guest feels at home.

Customer Reviews

Zero complaints, Austin was very welcoming and open to sharing about the Sicilian roots of his family. I brought my Sicilian wife (Italians somehow always manage to find other Italians while they're out and about, kind of like magnets or something) and our niece Josie with us for her birthday and it was honestly one of the highlights of my year. They've got historical family documents detailing their voyage over to New York from Sicily which manages to give the place an authentic, homey and endearing feel and they've got plenty of room for large groups and a game room which was unexpected. Their chicken tenders are surprisingly flavorful and delicious and although I don't typically like bar or tavern style pizza theirs was solid. Pro tip that the great grandson of the woman the restaurant's named in honor of shared with me; you can ask for the pizza(s) you order to be cut in standard, triangular pie pieces which slightly alters the taste of the pie so I'll try that next time I go

J
John A.

New in town, ordered a pizza for pickup after a long shift.. 10/10. The sauce, the crust, the bake- it was delicious. Love the crunchy light crust! Definitely will be a frequent spot going forwars. The staff was friendly and the place looks like a fun establish on a busy night. I ordered a small just for myself... do yourself a favor and get a large.. so worth it! I devoured it.

A
A A.

The chef special is epic. Regular pepperoni under the cheese, smaller pepperoni on top. WOW. Thin crusted with LOTS of cheese and meat. Left me feeling full with FOOD and not bread. This family run business is a friendly, delicious place to come for great food and a good time. Prices were super good, too! Highly recommend.

A
Arthur J.

Great pizza served up by lovely family and staff in a spacious location that is great for dining and can support parties and events. Pool table, fun games, large bar and plenty of space to stretch out. Family run restaurant for over 50 years! Fast and friendly delivery or dine in. Perfect way to support a local business and eat some delicious food too!

B
Brooke

Huge Thankyou to Jason and his staff for letting us have my dad's Celebration of life today at Josies. Yall done great and my family appreciates everything you guys did.

J
Josh P.

I tried Josie's for the 1st time tonight after seeing it mentioned on FB. The price was good for everything that we tried, & the crust and sauce were perfect. It's a bit of a drive for me, but definitely worth it.

J
Jesse W.