The Original Josie's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

The Original Josie's Pizza serves a robust menu packed with classic flavors. Guests can dive into large 14-inch pizzas, featuring options like the Large Cheese and Large Pepperoni, perfect for sharing. For a unique twist, try the Large B.L.T. pizza, a fan favorite that combines crispy bacon with fresh toppings. Smaller appetites can enjoy personal 10-inch pies, available in similar varieties.

Subs shine at this establishment too. The Super Italian Sub and the Stromboli Sub offer hearty bites, and wings add a spicy kick to any meal. Appetizers like garlic bread and chicken tenders promise a satisfying start before indulging in pizzas or dinners. With prices averaging just $9.23, dining here feels like a tasty bargain.

The Original Josie's Pizza Menu image 1
The Original Josie's Pizza Menu image 2
The Original Josie's Pizza Menu image 3
The Original Josie's Pizza Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Stromboli
Stromboli
Large Pepperoni
Large Pepperoni
Large Chef Salad
Large Chef Salad
Pepperoni and Sausage Light Peppers and Onions Well Done
Pepperoni and Sausage Light Peppers and Onions Well Done
Pepperoni Pizza Pepperoni Is Under the Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza Pepperoni Is Under the Cheese
Large Supreme
Large Supreme
Large Original Pepperoni
Large Original Pepperoni
Small Original Pepperoni
Small Original Pepperoni
B L T Pizza
B L T Pizza
The Original Josie's Pizza

The Original Josie's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Stepping into The Original Josie's Pizza feels like entering a friendly neighborhood spot. The interior balances casual dining and a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for families or friendly gatherings. Formica tables and warm lighting create a relaxed vibe, encouraging diners to linger over their meals.

The tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, tempting patrons before they even glance at the menu. The decor reflects a classic pizzeria with a homey touch, inviting everyone from pizza aficionados to casual diners looking for a quick bite. This local gem not only serves delicious food but also fosters a sense of community among its guests, making it a go-to spot on W Broad St.

The Original Josie's Pizza

About The Original Josie's Pizza Food and Specialties

The Original Josie's Pizza caters to pizza lovers with a flair for variety. Known for its tavern-style pizza, the crust is crispy and holds generous toppings without losing integrity. The selection includes 14-inch options for groups and 10-inch pizzas for individual diners, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Specialties like the Hawaiian pizza blend sweet pineapple with savory ham, while the Original Pepperoni pizza delights with the classic combo of zesty pepperoni and gooey cheese. For a twist, the BLT pizza incorporates garden-fresh lettuce and tomatoes along with bacon, making it a unique offering. Josie's also doesn't shy away from subs; the Italian and Meatball subs are hearty choices that round out an already diverse menu.

The Original Josie's Pizza

The Original Josie's Pizza embodies a commitment to quality, flavor, and community. By prioritizing fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, every menu item reflects dedication to both taste and customer satisfaction. The specialty pizzas and subs have loyal followings, with regulars often returning for their favorites.

The vision of Josie's extends beyond serving food. It aims to create a gathering space where memories are forged and friendships are strengthened over shared meals. Striving for excellence, The Original Josie's Pizza continues to be a staple in Columbus, ensuring that everyone recognizes it as the place to enjoy a truly good meal.